Thanksgiving Pie Orders - Are Open!

Due to last year's demand and filling in about three week's time, we are opening up Thanksgiving Orders earlier this year!  Every year at the holidays, we drop our pie prices to give back to our loyal customers and pie fans old and new.  All pies are $25.00, so they do book up fast.  You may also order from the Real Pie Menu which has different pricing.  We have alotted a certain number we know we can make preserving quality over quantity and when we are full, that's it folks!  Last Day to place Orders will be November 1 unless we reach capacity sooner; if so, we will post here!  Orders will be available for pickup November 21.  A confirmation email will follow your PayPal order.  Don't Delay!

Mom's Best Pumpkin

Our mother's Old Fashioned Pumpkin pie dressed up for the holiday with it's very best roasted pumpkin, and an array of warm spices that makes our Pumpkin truly special.  

Pumpkin Brownie Swirl 

Our signature creamy Pumpkin Pie with a Buttery Chocolate Crust, and a swirl of dark chocolate housemade brownie batter.  A uniquely tasty half traditional, half non-traditional pie that will satisfy both pumpkin pie fans and chocolate fans at your celebration.

Rosemary Caramel Apple Pecan

Our signature Salted Caramel Apple Pecan gets a fall boost from a hint of Rosemary in our housemade caramel, topped with our Buttery brown sugar/oat butter crumble, gobs of caramel, and toasty, crunchy pecans.  

Dutch Cherry Nantucket Cranberry

Our signature Washington Cherry pie blended with both fresh Nantucket cranberries and dried cherries gives this pie a beautiful pie hue and fall flavor.  Topped with our signature Buttery brown sugar/oat/butter crumble and a dusting of cinnamon sugar.

Maple Apple Walnut

Our signature Cider Apple pie all gussied up with pure maple syrup, topped with a Buttery brown sugar/oat/butter/toasted walnut streusel.  Warm, vibrant, fall flavors are the standout in this pie with Granny Smith & Gravenstein apples baked to perfection. Dusted with housemade maple sugar, and a maple glaze drizzle.

Salted Caramel Bourbon Chocolate Pecan

Get the best of all the Pecan pie worlds in this decadent pie a cross between traditional Pecan and Chocolate Pecan, topped with housemade salted caramel and a hint of sea salt.  *Traditional Butterscotch Pecan also available.  Please specify by email after ordering.

Salted Caramel Banana Cream

A new creation, a fall twist on our Traditional Banana Cream!  We infuse salty caramel into our vanilla bean/banana pastry cream, layer it over a base of housemade dulce de leche, with fresh sliced bananas.  Topped with whipped cream spiked with a hint of holiday rum, and sprinkled with caramel sugar.  We've turned summer banana cream into a fall delight.

Salted Caramel Bourbon Pecan Pumpkin

Get the best of all the pie worlds in this Pumpkin Pie, spiked with a bit of Bourbon, and topped with Pecans and Salty Caramel.  The perfect Thanksgiving Pie for everyone! 

Caramel Apple Fig & Toffee

A new fall take on Caramel Apple Pie - caramel Granny Smith Apples, get a few dollops of Fig Butter, another layer of caramel Granny Smith's, and a hefty sprinkle of house made English Toffee.  Topped with a new all butter/sugar crumble.  It's a fall celebration in a pie.

Mile High Cranberry Pomegranate Cherry Meringue

Our traditional Cherry Pie gets some warm and cozy fall cheer with tart cranberries, orange zest and pomegranate juice for a sweet-tart rosy pie.  Baked in our signature graham crust and topped with a swirl of toasty marshmallow meringue and pomegranate seeds.  The pilgrims would have loved it!

*No substitutions allowed.  Cancellations will result in store credit only.