Christmas Orders - Order Goodies Here!

We will take a limited amount of pie orders just as with Thanksgiving, as we will remain without staff for everyone's safety until the end of Covid (whenever that may be).  We thank you for your support and understanding as we strive to maintain quality and keep you safe!  Order goodies here by clicking the Paypal button by the item you desire; a confirmation will be sent by email two weeks before Christmas. Cheers!

Christmas Bumbleberry

A unique blend of Strawberries, Blueberries, Raspberries, Rose Rhubarb & Pink Lady Apples give this pie a gorgeous holiday hue.  Topped with our Brown Sugar/Butter/Oat Crumble.

Pumpkin Meringue Tart

A Roasted Pepita, Praline & Honey Graham Crust, filled with creamy Pumpkin filling, topped with billowy Cinnamon Marshmallow Meringue.

Chocolate Coconut Cream

Our signature Cognac Coconut Cream Pie with an Oreo Chocolate Crust, a few crushed Oreos mixed in, toasted Coconut and a mountain of Whipped Cream and Chocolate Curls.

Salted Caramel Fudge Galette

Our open faced super flaky Galette, filled with a Brownie like Chocolate, topped with housemade Salted Rum Caramel.  Sprinkled with flecks of Maldon Sea Salt, striking against a Turbinado sugared crust. A years long shop favorite.  

Below Pies Are Sold Out:

Santa's Christmas Morning Quiche

(Sold Out)

Our signature all butter crust Quiche, speckled with Roasted Red Peppers, Ham, Bacon, Scallions, Caramelized Onions, Cheddar & Gruyere baked into a creamy Quiche egg custard.  Who wants to cook on Christmas morning?  Simply warm in an oven or microwave and serve with your favorite condiments.

Salted Butterscotch Chess

(Sold Out)

Our award winning Brown Sugar Caramel Chess pie with the addition of creamy Butterscotch chips!  Freckled with Maldon Sea Salt flakes and baked into our award winning butter pastry crust. A southern favorite year-round, deliciously creamy and dense at the same time.

Holiday Chocolate Peppermint Chess

(Sold Out)

Think the best, gooiest brownie pie you could want, with a slight infusion of Espresso &  white chocolate Peppermint Bark bits!  While the pie is cooling post-bake, Starlight Peppermint Candies are inserted into each slice for a festive and delicious twist!  You'll want to serve up some Vanilla Bean Ice Cream or Whipped Cream alongside every delicious bite.

Cranberry Cherry Frangipane Galette

(Sold Out)

Our mini Galettes are so popular, we decided to go big!  We make this every holiday season - a super flaky butter open face pastry different than our traditional pie crust, holds fresh Nantucket Cranberries and Northern Sour Cherries that sit upon a light blanket of snowy buttery Almond Frangipane Filling.  Buttery, crisp, with pastry bursting into shards with each bite.  A dark chocolate drizzle completes this festive unique pie. A Knowrealitypie original and seasonal tradition.

Hot Buttered Rum Cream

(Sold Out)

What can we say?  A special butter rum infused syrup is added to our Vanilla Bean Pastry Cream, with a blend of Nutmeg, Cinnamon and spices for a pie reminiscent of that favorite holiday hot toddy.  Gently spooned into our all butter crust, and topped with a Rum Whipped Cream, White Chocolate curls, and a sprinkle of Nutmeg.  Adults only please on this one. 

Whiskey Chocolate Pecan

(Sold Out)

Our award winning Butterscotch Pecan pie gets a bit of Texas Whiskey, and a smattering of premium Dark Chocolate Disks sandwiched in between those toasted Pecans and brown sugar butter filling!  Baked in our all butter crust, and topped with a bit of chocolate ganache  to get that party started.

All Is Berry & Bright

(Sold Out)

Our Triple Berry Cabernet, with the addition of Cranberries for a sweet and tart berry delicious pie.  The Cabernet gives this pie a slight tang - you know you love it but can't figure out why. A pretty lattice crust plays peek a boo with all those deep vibrant berry colors. Another KCRW award winner here and back for the holidays.

Gingersnap Pumpkin

(Sold Out)

A hand mashed Honey Butter Gingersnap Crust holds our Mom's Best Pumpkin Pie filling - not your average pumpkin pie custard, this one is all dressed up with warm winter spices.  Garnished with Whipped Cream Rosettes, Candied Ginger, and Gingersnap crumbles.  Forget that store bought stuff - this is the real deal.

Dutch Toffee Apple Pecan

(Sold Out)

Our three-blend Apple Pie, featuring Pink Lady, Granny Smith & Fuji apples with an infusion of Caramel Toffee, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg and allspice.  Baked in our butter crust, topped with our Brown Sugar/Buttery/Oat Pecan Crumble, Caramel Swirls, and Toffee Bits.

Winter Wonderland Love Cake

(Sold Out)

Christmas is the only time of year we make our Southern Soul Food Vanilla Bean Love Cake in layer form!  A buttery, two layer 8 inch cake with our secret Vanilla Bean Butter Frosting, complete with Christmas Blue & Silver Snowflake sprinkle decorations.  A refreshing change from all those darned pies! 

Lemon Raspberry Meringue

(Sold Out)

Mile High Lemon Meringue pie features tart Lemon Curd, a thin layer of fresh Raspberry housemade jam, and billowy toasted Marshmallow Meringue in our all butter crust!  Garnished with Raspberry Dust & Lemon zest - refreshingly holiday and festive. You will only see this pie during the holiday season or at the peak of summer.