* Note: Memorial Day & Father's Day Orders Close May 20! We do not accept orders by phone. Click on the PayPal button adjacent the pie, and within a day or so a confirmation email will be sent to you. Then, we discuss pickup day and time via email. Please allow one week lead time on weekly whole pie orders - no exceptions. Menu offerings are updated seasonally and often. Pies are $36.00-$45.00, 9 3/4 inches and generally serve 8-9. Please check availability of Boysenberry, Rhubarb & Blueberry before ordering! Cheers!
Triple Berry Cabernet
Our award winning Triple Berry Blend, steeped in a smidge of Cabernet wine, in our signature award winning double butter crust pie. There's a reason it's a shop sellout and was voted Best Fruit Pie by KCRW - yum. *Available in Triple Berry Cabernet Chocolate Chip Crumble also and GF. Specify by email.
Espresso Butterscotch Pecan
Our KCRW award winning Espresso Pecan Pie, laced with butterscotch chips - a brown sugar butter filling and hint of Espresso and loads of toasted pecans - no corn syrup here! *Available in Chocolate Chip Pecan also. Specify by email.
Sweet, dark, tart cherries shipped to us specially from the Northwest, debut in this fresh take on boring Cherry pie. Adorned with a brown sugar/butter/oat crumble topping or on request, lattice butter top crust. Folks tell us they have never had a cherry pie this good. We have to second that. GF Available.
Cognac Coconut Cream
My Mom had it right oh so many years ago - and the demand for our cream pies proves it. Her signature pastry cream recipe lives on in this creamy, coconut filled pie with a hint of Cognac and vanilla bean paste. Buttery, creamy, coconut delight. In our signature award winning honey graham butter crust and topped with whipped cream, toasty coconut, and housemade coconut sugar. Thanks Mom. *Black Bottom Available on Paypal link.
Mexican Chocolate Dulce
Yes, it's that same cream pie base from Mom - infused with organic Vahlrona dark and semisweet chocolate, a hint of espresso powder to enhance that chocolate, cinnamon and piled onto a housemade Dulce de Leche caramel bottom, with a honey-cocoa graham crust. Folks request this pie more than any other cream pie in our shop. Topped with whipped cream and specialty French chocolate sprinkles.
Lemon Basil Ice Box Pie
Pink Lemonade Ice Box Pie
A twist on our Award Winning Key Lime Pie, we use a blend of tangy lemons in these summer ready refrigerator pies. Baked in our honey graham crust, with a hint of fresh summer basil, topped with whipped cream rosettes lemon sugar and lemon wafers. Cool, creamy, delicious.
Sea Salt Brown Sugar Caramel Chess
Our award winning spin on the traditional Southern Chess Pie includes loads of butter and brown sugar which bake up into a creamy, caramel wonder. Topped with Sea Salt hot out of the oven for that extra sweet, creamy, salty bite of Southern heaven. *Chocolate Chip Caramel Chess & Chocolate Fudge Chess also available.
Classic Mexican Key Lime
Our signature Key Lime Pie gets a twist from fresh California Mexican & Key Limes, a cinnamon salty Honey Graham Cracker crust, and a secret whipped cream topping piled mile high with lime zest. Refreshing, sweet/tart, sweet/salty.
Blueberry Blackberry Bliss
Northern Blueberries meet fresh summer Blackberries and combined, the duo make an exceptionally great tasting pie. Topped with our butter/oat/brown sugar crumble or two crust - specify by email.
Peanut Butter Buckeye
Chocolate cocoa-honey graham crust gets a whopping creamy, peanut butter filling, topped with a thin layer of chocolate ganache, whipped cream rosettes with a hint of peanut butter and mini Buckeye peanut butter/chocolate candies. So much better than a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup.
Have your cake and eat it too! Our vanilla been rum pastry cream stuffed with house baked cake chunks right in our very own signature butter crust. Topped with whipped cream a dusting of colorful rainbow confetti sprinkles. Either vanilla with vanilla butter cake, or chocolate with chocolate cake. Very festive indeed.
Spring Strawberry Pineapple Rhubarb
As if Strawberry Rhubarb wasn't already Springy fresh and delicious, we have found this to be a huge hit in our shop, so here it is. Strawberries, Rhubarb and Pineapple create a wonderful flavor and bright hue - topped with our signature Brown Sugar/Butter/Oat crumble. An Easter & Mom's Day Favorite. *GF Option available.
Our signature 10 inch Quiche, baked in our award winning butter crust with choice of fillings - Rosemary Ham, Potato, Asparagus & Bella Mushroom, Bacon, Spring Onion, Roasted Corn, Roasted Red Pepper, Tomato & Mozzarella, or Blistered Tomato, Pesto, Basil, Red Onion & Parmesan. Doesn't get any better than this.
Sea Salt Caramel Mango Rum Passion
Our KCRW award winning pie in whole pie form. Mangos, passionfruit, housemade salted rum caramel topped with our Brown Sugar/Oat/Butter Crumble and laced with housemade Butterscotch Caramel and flecks of Maldon Sea Salt. There's a reason why we won an award for this creation.
Jeannie's Lemon Meringue
My Mom's classic Buttery Lemony Curd, topped with our secret Marshmallow Meringue swirls and torched to perfection. Available with Raspberry or Blueberry bottom layer as well.
Old Fashioned Chocolate or Banana Cream
When I was young, Easter was all about Mom's home-made Cream Pies, either Coconut, Banana, Chocolate, or Peanut Butter Banana. Our signature pastry cream, either Chocolate or Banana, topped with whipped cream. Plain and simple but tastes like a million bucks. We've added this bit of nostalgia to the list upon request.
Classic Brown Sugar Peach
Peach Apricot Bellini
It's Peach season! Special techniques bring out the natural juices and sugars in Spring's finest. Nestled in a lattice butter crust or with our signature Brown Sugar/Butter/Oat Crumble. Peach Apricot Bellini gets a boost from a splash of fruity Prosecco. Almost better than Mom's specialty!
Classic Summer Boysenberry
Please check availability before ordering! Boysenberry fruit seasons are limited here in So Cal. This is a classic, two crust, Boysenberry pie at its best when we can find the berries!
Salted Caramel Fudge Crostata
An old Knowrealitypie original, back on the menu! A free-form Italian Crostata Pie, with a fudge filling and Salted Caramel Top flecked with Maldon Sea Salt. This pastry is super flaky - a uniquely impressive and delicious pie.
Seasonal Fresh Strawberry
A shortbread cookie base, holds the season's finest fresh strawberries upon a light vanilla pastry cream base. Topped with a housemade glaze, and whipped cream rosettes. Simple decadence at it's finest.
Spiced Apple Crumble
Salted Caramel Apple Pecan
Choose either of these homey, secret ingredient, triple blend apple pies truly to die for. Warmed up with cozy spices, these pies are shop sellouts and ordered year round. Mom's special recipe close to my heart.
Death By Chocolate (Raspberry)
A new creation! A chocolate shortbread cookie base holds the richest, creamiest decadent chocolate filling with a layer of raspberry jam. Topped with chocolate whipped cream rosettes, fresh raspberries shaped like a heart and raspberry dust.
Earl Grey Tea
Yes. We most certainly did. We infuse white chocolate mousse cream with Earl Grey Tea - floral, mild, wispy, and pile it atop a chocolate ganache base in our signature all butter award winning crust. Topped with whipped cream and crushed salty pistachios. Deliciously sinful.
Seasonal Fresh Fruit Tart
Our secret Champagne Shortbread Cookie Crust gets a thin layer of lightly sweetened vanilla bean pastry cream, and an array of seasonal fresh fruits. So pretty, light, and fresh - the perfect ending to a summer party or bbq.
Seasonal Rotating Pies - shop based throughout the year:
Strawberry Lemon Meringue
Pumpkin Dulce de Leche
Pumpkin Nutella Swirl
Peanuts & Pepsi
Banoffee (Banana Caramel Toffee)
Mexican Key Lime
Classic Key Lime
Atlantic Beach Citrus
Lemon Ginger Icebox
Peanut Butter Buckeye
Coffee Toffee Pecan
Sour Cream Peach
Birthday Cake Pie
Blueberry Cherry Apricot
Kona Mocha Brownie
Cognac Coconut Pineapple
Salted Caramel Apple Pecan
Old Fashioned Butterscotch
Seasonal Rotating Savory:
Shortrib Mac & Cheese
Oaxacan Mexican Mole
Sloppy Joe & Cornbread
Green Chile Chicken
Sweet Potato Chili
Julia's Beef Bourguignon
Corned Beef & Cabbage