* Note:  Pie Orders Re-Open for Weekend Pickup January 10. We do not accept orders by phone.  Click on the PayPal button adjacent the pie, and within a day or so a confirmation email will be sent to you.  Then, we discuss pickup day and time via email.  Please allow one week lead time on weekly whole pie orders. Menu offerings are updated seasonally and often.  Pies are $25.00-$38.00, 9 3/4 inches and generally serve 8-9. Cheers! 

Triple Berry Cabernet

Our award winning Triple Berry Blend, steeped in a smidge of Cabernet wine, in our signature award winning double butter crust pie.  There's a reason it's a shop sellout and was voted Best Fruit Pie by KCRW - yum. *Available in Triple Berry Cabernet Chocolate Chip also.  Specify by email.

Espresso Butterscotch Pecan

Our award winning Espresso Pecan Pie, laced with butterscotch chips - a brown sugar butter filling and loads of toasted pecans - no corn syrup here!  

Washington Cherry 

Sweet, dark, tart cherries shipped to us specially from the Northwest, debut in this fresh take on winter Cranberry Cherry pie.  Adorned with a brown sugar/butter/oat crumble topping or on request, butter top crust.  Folks tell us they have never had a cherry pie this good.  We have to second that.  

Cognac Coconut Cream

My Mom had it right oh so many years ago - and our cream pies prove it.  Her signature pastry cream recipe lives on in this creamy, coconut filled pie with a hint of Cognac and vanilla bean paste.  Buttery, creamy, coconut delight.  In our signature award winning butter crust and topped with whipped cream, toasty coconut, and housemade coconut sugar.  Thanks Mom.

Mexican Chocolate Dulce

Yes, it's that same cream pie base from Mom - infused with organic Vahlrona dark and semisweet chocolate, a hint of espresso powder to enhance that chocolate, cinnamon and piled onto a housemade Dulce de Leche caramel bottom.  Folks request this pie more than any other cream pie in our shop.  Topped with whipped cream and specialty French chocolate sprinkles. 

Earl Grey Tea

A new pie!  White chocolate pastry cream is infused with Earl Grey Tea, scooped onto a silky Chocolate Ganache bottom in our signature butter crust pastry, and topped with Whipped Cream and chopped salty pistachios.  Fresh, light, happy, floral, delicious. 

Sea Salt Brown Sugar Chess

Our spin on the traditional Southern Chess Pie includes loads of butter and brown sugar which bake up into a creamy, caramel wonder.  Topped with Sea Salt hot out of the oven for that extra sweet, creamy, salty bite of Southern heaven.  

​Atlantic Beach Citrus

Our signature Key Lime Pie gets a twist from fresh Lemon Juice, and a mixed Saltine/Honey Graham Cracker cinnamon crust.  Refreshing, sweet/tart, sweet/salty.  Topped with Whipped Cream and citrus dust.

Blueberry Buttermilk Old Fashioned

Traditional southern Buttermilk Pie laced with fresh blueberries provide a creamy, rich yet light, decadent pie.  A new addition to Knowrealitypie which will rotate with other seasonal berries and a Pecan Billionaire's version through spring.  

Spiced Apple Crumble

Our signature Apple Filling with extra cinnamon, ginger and warm spices that make it an exceptionally great apple pie.  Topped with our butter/oat/brown sugar crumble.  Mom's absolute finest just dolled up a little.  Yum. *Salted Caramel Apple Pecan also available.  Please specify at checkout or by email.

Peanut Butter Buckeye

Chocolate cookie crust gets a whopping creamy, peanut butter filling, topped with a thin layer of chocolate ganache, peanut butter whipped cream and mini Buckeye peanut butter/chocolate candies.  So much better than a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup.


Our signature 10 inch Quiche, baked in our award winning butter crust with choice of fillings - Spinach, Tomato, Gruyere, Caramelized Onion, Bacon, Cheddar, Roasted Red Pepper, Chive, or Southwest Green Chile & Pepperjack.  Doesn't get any better than this.

Soul Food Southern Love Cake

Our all butter, secret recipe family heirloom Southern Soul Food Love Cake - a buttery, super vanilla layer cake with a unique lip smacking frosting.  Decorated with our signature crust heart - a 9 inch layer cake unlike any other and always a shop sell out.

Seasonal  Rotating Pies - shop based throughout the year:

Lemon Bar Pie

Sweet Potato Cornbread

Chai Glazed Sweet Potato Pecan

Apple Blueberry Walnut

Pumpkin Dulce de Leche

Mexican Lime

Classic Key Lime

Atlantic Beach Citrus

Peanut Butter Buckeye

Boysenberry Bordeaux

Bourbon Toffee Pecan

Sour Cream Peach

Georgia Peanut Butter

Kona Mocha Brownie

Salted Caramel Mango Rum

Cognac Coconut Pineapple

Salted Caramel Apple Pecan

Old Fashioned Butterscotch

Seasonal Rotating Savory:

Buffalo Cauliflower

Shortrib Mac & Cheese

Oaxacan Mexican Mole

Sloppy Joe & Cornbread

Green Chile Chicken

Sweet Potato Chili

Julia's Beef Bourguignon

Corned Beef & Cabbage